Homemade Velveeta Cheese Recipe! So Tasty!

Homemade Velveeta Cheese // thepapermama.com

The other day I found this on Pinterest…. Homemade frickin’ Velveeta cheese. I really love cheese…. It’s pretty much a necessity in my life. I had to make this IMMEDIATELY! I mean, yeah: cheddar cheese is almost the same thing… but there’s something magical about Velveeta. Unlike cheese, it doesn’t turn into greasy mess when you melt it. It’s just creamy cheesy goodness. Toss in some tomatoes or beans into this cheese and you have an amazing dip.

We went ahead with a grilled cheese sandwich for our first Homemade Velveeta Cheese experiment. The result: delicious. We did just plain cheese for our kiddo and added spinach and bacon for us. PLUS, tomato soup. So yummy. This pinterest find is a WIN.

Homemade Velveeta Cheese // thepapermama.com

I researched about 5 different recipes and decided this was the recipe for me (I only adjusted the salt and types of cheese amounts). I hope you check it out (unless you hate cheese, then don’t… ha):

Homemade Velveeta Cheese

Recipe adapted from, America’s Test Kitchen via The taste Tester

1 Tablespoon water

1 1/2 teaspoons powdered gelatin (unflavored)

1 cup colby jack cheese, grated*

1/2 cup sharp cheddar cheese, grated*

1 Tablespoon non-fat or whole dry milk powder

1/2 teaspoon salt

1/8 teaspoon cream of tartar

1/2 cup + 2 tablespoons whole milk

Directions: 

– Line a small pan with plastic wrap (with the wrap hanging over the edge). The recipe called for a 5 x 4 bread pan, but I used a 5 x 9 x 1 inch high pan. Worked fine.

– Place the 1 Tablespoon of water in a small bowl and sprinkle the gelatin on top. Let sit for 5 minutes.

– Pulse your grated cheese, dried milk, salt, and cream of tartar in a food processor (about 5 times).

– Bring the milk to a boil over medium heat (it starts to boil pretty quick). When it reaches a boil, remove it from the heat and stir in the gelatin until it dissolves.

– Pour the milk mixture into a liquid measuring cup. With your food processor running add the milk into the cheese mixture. Blend until the mixture is combine and velvety smooth.

– Immediately pour the cheese mixture into your prepared pan. Chill in a fridge for 3 hours or overnight.

Homemade Velveeta Cheese // thepapermama.com

This is delicious. I mean… yeah, it’s cheese… BUT, it’s just like Velveeta cheese. There’s something different about Velveeta. It’s creamy and fantastic. This is a wonderful substitute. Let me know if you try it! It’s so good. I mean: cheese. Also…. try and take photos of a grilled cheese sandwich while your kiddo is watching… it’s almost impossible, “Mama, I’m Soooooooo starving hungry.” Ha!

– Chelsey


12 comments

  • Tessa on said:

    Thank you. I've been looking for a Velveeta substitute because I want to make a cheeseburger soup recipe I just found. Have you used this for other things besides sandwiches? Just wondering how it will work in my soup.

  • Laurie on said:

    I am just enchanted with pintrest!! So when you pair velveeta and it, a match made in heaven!! Love this, and so glad it worked out.

  • TishaO on said:

    who ever even knew you could make your own Velveeta?! Awesome!! it even looks like velveeta!
    thanks for sharing the recipe!

  • Ashley on said:

    I pinned this last night and can not wait to try it! I know how bad velveeta is but it is just so much better for grilled cheese!

  • Nancy on said:

    This brings back memories! My Mama used to make Grilled Cheese sandwiches with Velveeta cheese and they were the best! But I did not know you could make HOMEMADE Velveeta cheese!! Thanks for sharing!

    • The Paper Mama on said:

      I didn't know either… thank goodness for Pinterest. Hee. 😀

  • The BabbyMama on said:

    I did not even know this is something you could DIY! Wow!

Leave a comment!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *